Fing Test Speed - Noticeable differences

I updated fing desktop today and a new feature was introduced call speed test.  It has apparently pulled date from the past few days/week and shows pretty dismal speed performances.  I ran Spectrum's Speed Test, Okla Speed Test, and Mlab's speed test and compared them to a Fing speed test.  Fing Speed Test shows download of 112.8 while all of the others showed downloads of 480.  Not sure how best to report issues but this is a pretty severe discrepancy that needs further review by Fing support.
Tagged:

Answers

  • Marc
    Marc Moderator, Beta Tester Posts: 3,141
    250 Answers 1,000 Likes 2500 Comments 250 Awesomes
    ✭✭✭✭✭✭✭
    edited January 13, 2022 #2
    @millewg001, did you try running it multiple times and if so what the discrepancy consistent?  

    On my setup, the first time it ran, it was over 100mbps shy of the others (See below) but was significantly more accurate on subsequent runs.

    Note I pay for 300mbps and I generally see about 320ish download speeds on average.

    @Robin_from_Fing and @Dylan_From_Fing tagging you folks for awareness...



    Thats Daphnee, she's a good dog...
    Dylan_From_Fing
  • millewg001
    millewg001 Member Posts: 6
    First Anniversary First Comment
    I ran ring speed test (scheduled) over a couple of days.  All results were significantly lower than running other speed tests.  I will try running Fing speed test a few times then retest against the other programs and see if there is an improvement
  • PeterB
    PeterB Member Posts: 4
    Second Anniversary First Comment Photogenic
    I am also finding significant differences in Download speed results using the Fing desktop app (2.8.0). The Fing results seem to be all over the place but mostly showing between 10 and 20mbps when Ookla and Mlabs show between 95 and 100+. Sometimes the Fing reports a correct speed. I am subscribed to Full Fibre100 from Zen. Oddly the upload speed seems to be accurate and consistent.  I have powered down the Fing box and powered up, rebooted my PC but it makes no difference.  I have reinstalled the Fing Desktop app (2.8.0) but still no difference. This has been going on since last August but I have not had the time to investigate.  Could it be that my Fing Box has developed a fault? Any other suggestions/ 
  • Zach
    Zach Member Posts: 5
    Second Anniversary First Comment Photogenic
    I also have found that Fing speed tests are completely unreliable.  Version 2.8.0 is consistently registering speeds 100 Mbps or more slower than every other test I can run.  Using all of the popular speed tests, I have tried different servers in an attempt to get results even close to Fing but no luck.  I have tried multiple connection points on my network using multiple known good cables and the results are the same.  I run back to back test after test and Fing is generally around 40% to 70% slower.  Maybe 1 out of 10 tests on Fing will show a more realistic speed.  Researching on this forum and finding this topic with posts from 2 years ago is very disappointing.  There are a lot of great features with the Fingbox but speed test is clearly not one of them.  I used the monthly report to open a case with my internet provider claiming that I wasn't getting the speed I was paying for and that turned out very embarrassing.  Hello Fing; any comments or progress on this issue?
  • CAJUNGENE
    CAJUNGENE Member Posts: 1
    First Comment
    I have the same issue.  My Fing speed test shows a Download of 25Mbps and Speed Tests from Ookla and DSL reports show speeds > 480Mbps.  So much for a reliable Fing tool. Since this issues goes back a long time does anyone know when it will be fixed?
  • Karl_From_Fing
    Karl_From_Fing Administrator, Beta Tester Posts: 450
    100 Comments 25 Likes 5 Answers 5 Awesomes
    ✭✭✭

    The Internet Speed Test aims at giving you a measure of a realistic speed achievable with real Internet services, not a formal speed sustainable just within the “last mile”.

    For example, Fast.com is provided by Netflix to measure the real speed to the closest Netflix video servers. Speedtest.com is a commercial service getting its revenues from selling the data to service providers and, by default, it gives you the speed to a server within your service provider network, not the speed of a service on the global Internet.

    The Fingbox Internet Speed Test is provided by our partner Measurement Lab, one of the most trusted independent labs for network measurement, backed by academic institutions and used by Google and other large Internet companies.
    Given the different location of test servers and unique methodology, M-Lab test results may differ from other commercial services. M-Lab servers are located in the most important exchange nodes of the global Internet, you can see the test locations here https://www.measurementlab.net/status/.


    Speed Tests from both the Fing App and Fingbox are not meant to be an absolute test of a connection's abilities. The test is intended to give you an average or baseline of the performance of your network.

    It acts as a known reference point to refer to letting you know when things have changed or are not working the way they normally do. If the results change from their normal range, the user should look into more detailed test to see what is causing the issue.

    Speed Test runs at a low priority and can be interrupted by other programs that take priority over the test. This can cause lower-than-expected results.


    For a full list of useful troubleshoot tips and guides, please visit our knowledge base at https://help.fing.com/.

    For any further queries, please visit our Fing community here: https://community.fing.com


    You can watch our YouTube tutorial on how to navigate the 'Internet' tab here: Introducing the Fing Internet Tab: Automated Internet Speed Tests & More - YouTube